I did need to check that box in the settings. Thank you.
Although,
the login widget that shows their membership status will show that the account is expired
I don't see anywhere that the account is 'expired', not in the widget area or the profile area either.
But also... I am wondering if I can edit the text that comes up on a page when access has expired. This is what it says now- "Your account has expired. Please renew your account to gain access to this content." It would be cool if I could add a link to direct them to pay again, or to contact the admin.