Ok, so I honestly don't know if I've fixed the problem or just side stepped it. Now when I go to my page FoodBodyFitness.com, I see at the bottom "Your Shopping Cart is Empty." Now, I don't know if this is just my computer remembering that I deleted the original order it had when it randomly placed an item in the cart after adding the shortcode [always_show_wp_shopping_cart] to the end of my page or not.
But as of right now it is working and the cart is not just showing up everytime I go to Women's or Men's Apparel. But, I do not have another computer to check this on.
mbrsolution: Removing all of the shortcodes and just adding [always_show_wp_shopping_cart] to the end still leaves me with the same problem of just showing my hat as an item considering it is the last piece of apparel on the page.
So as of right now this is how the visual looks and it "seems to be working:
[wp_cart_display_product name="Food Body Fitness Pink Racerback" price="15.95" thumbnail="http://foodbodyfitness.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/FBF-Womens-Pink-resize.jpg" shipping="0.001" var1="Size|Large"
[show_wp_shopping_cart]
[wp_cart_display_product name="Food Body Fitness Green Tank" price="13.95" thumbnail="http://foodbodyfitness.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/FBF-Womens-Blue-resize.jpg" shipping="0.001" var1="Size|Small|Large"
[show_wp_shopping_cart]
[wp_cart_display_product name="Food Body Fitness Blue Running Shorts" price="14.95" thumbnail="http://foodbodyfitness.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/FBF-Womens-Shorts-Blue-resize.jpg" shipping="0.001" var1="Size|Small|Medium|Large"
[show_wp_shopping_cart]
[wp_cart_display_product name="Food Body Fitness Black Hat" price="19.95" thumbnail="http://foodbodyfitness.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/FBF-Hat-Black-resize.jpg" shipping="0.001"
[show_wp_shopping_cart]
[always_show_wp_shopping_cart]